Patti Smith: Twelve

And then there is the other side of an album of covers. Patti Smith's "Twelve." Yes, the "Twelve" refers to the number of tracks.

From Jimi Hendrix to Tears for Fears, Nirvana to the Allman Brothers, Smith manages to at least break even, if not come up a little bit ahead by the time of the album.

When doing a cover (just one or a whole album), you have to take in to account how the fans will respond. If you end up just doing an uninspired, flat out cover (see: Bryan Ferry's "Dylaneseque") you could alienate the fan-base. If you do too much experimentation and alteration, you may be heralded for creative, but again shunned for destroying a "classic."

Smith plays it safe. There's not a lot of stretching the musical boundaries (except for the banjo in "Smells Like Teen Spirit;" It works!), but she does some faithful work to bring her back to the front of pop culture.

Where I feel "Are You Experienced?" failed a bit in Smith's hands, she manages an even-keeled "Everybody Wants to Rule the World." "Gimme Shelter" is belted out with some serious force to give Mick a run for his money, but Paul Simon's "Boy in the Bubble" feels a bit awkward.

Where she does things so very right is the Beatles' "Within you without you," Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit," and the Allman's "Midnight Rider."

In the end: Again, this is the good side of a cover album. It feels like Patti Smith took special care in picking these songs and worked them up to play nicely with her voice. Like I said, it's no world-shattering re-imagination, but it's 12 songs from the pop-vernacular performed for us with Smith's unique vocal strains. Worth at least a once-through.

Technorati Tagged: Patti Smith | Cover Album | Rock | 2007